|Reason to Believe|
|Season 6, Episode 1|
|Air date||27 Sep 1997|
|Written by||Philip Gerson|
|Directed by||Terrence O'Hara|
Moment of Truth, Part 2
All That Matters
After Sully goes over the cliff with O'Connor (end of previous episode), Dr. Mike won't give up searching for him with hopes of finding him alive and Matthew resigns as the town sheriff to help. When Sully's best friend Daniel hears about the incident, he returns to town to help with the search himself. Meanwhile, Sully is seriously hurt and in need of medical attention if he's going to survive.
While Dr. Mike is searching, Sgt. McKay sends a man to follow her, thinking she may know where he is, and Dorothy goes north to see Cloud Dancing and tell him that Sully is missing.The man sent to follow Dr. Mike goes back to report that they don't know where Sully is, but Cloud Dancing is with the Northern Cheyenne in the Tongue River Valley.
- Wanted posters for Sully arrive - $1,000 bounty
- Robert E., Jake, and Hank are also looking for Sully to help Dr. Mike. Hank and Jake quit after 4 days, Robert E decides to stay in town after renegades attack town
- The Palmer Creek Reservation is closed and the renegades that are caught will be brought to East Fork
- Brian arranges things so he can join the search when Dr. Mike and Daniel decide to stay out until they find Sully.